According to data from 2021, the fatality rate for full-time construction laborers was 9.4 per 100,000 workers, making it the third-highest fatality rate among private industries. Construction work poses significant hazards, including working at heights and handling dangerous equipment. Given these circumstances, prioritizing construction safety has become increasingly crucial due to a convergence of various factors.
Recently passed federal legislation like the Inflation Reduction Act is expected to increase the number of building and infrastructure projects significantly soon. This increased workload could put more laborers in harm’s way. The construction industry is also facing challenges from a chronic labor shortage and supply chain snags. Financial challenges for construction firms and workers doing more with less can be a deadly combo. That's why construction workers must have the right business insurance coverage.
We set out to reveal the most dangerous states for construction workers by looking at several key factors. We examined construction injury, illness, and fatality rates in each state, along with OSHA inspection, citation, and enforcement data. We scored each state based on these factors to determine a final construction safety score. The ranking should be helpful for many with ties to the construction industry and occupational safety and health.
Big Takeaways:
- Montana is a construction danger zone. Montana emerges as a construction danger zone, securing the top spot as the most perilous state for construction workers. Following closely behind are Kansas, Florida, Nebraska, and Colorado, completing the top five list of the most hazardous states for construction.
- More OSHA enforcement is better. The importance of robust OSHA enforcement becomes evident as states with weaker inspection, citation, and fine protocols also experience higher rates of injuries and fatalities. The correlation between stringent OSHA enforcement and enhanced worker safety is unmistakable.
- The dangerous Midwest and South. Construction safety concerns are particularly pronounced in the Midwest and South regions, with a majority of the top 10 most dangerous states concentrated in these areas. This concentration may be attributed to the comparatively lesser safety oversight from state and federal inspectors in traditionally conservative states.
Most Dangerous States for Construction Workers 2023
Construction work is dangerous all across the U.S., but laborers in some states have it worse than others. Based on our analysis, there could be several reasons for this. We analyzed all 50 states and the District of Columbia and ranked them by injury, illness, and fatality rates from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) and inspection, citation, and penalty data from the Occupational Safety & Health Administration (OSHA).
All these factors were critical for determining which states were most dangerous for construction laborers. Higher injury and fatality rates obviously show a state is more dangerous, but our reasoning behind OSHA scoring was slightly different. One would think more OSHA fines and citations mean a state is more hazardous, but the data showed the exact opposite. This led us to believe that less OSHA oversight made the state more dangerous for the typical construction employee.
A note about the data: OSHA and BLS data for occupational safety and health is known to be full of gaps, and this is what we found, as well. We excluded four states from the ranking because they were missing more than one piece of critical data: South Dakota, North Dakota, Rhode Island, and New Hampshire.
Here are more big takeaways from the analysis:
- The fatal four states. Montana stands out as the most dangerous state for construction workers, surpassing all others in terms of fatal incidents in 2021. Louisiana, Georgia, and Arkansas also reported alarmingly high fatality rates within the construction industry.
- Bigger isn’t always more dangerous. The number of construction laborers in a state doesn't necessarily indicate its safety level. For instance, California had the highest number of laborers in 2021 but ranked in the middle when it came to overall safety.
- On their own in New Mexico. New Mexico takes the lead for the weakest OSHA enforcement among all U.S. states, based on factors such as the number of inspections, citations, and total fines per laborer. Similarly, states like Arizona, South Carolina, and Kansas also demonstrated inadequate OSHA oversight.
Several persistent construction industry challenges could hamper safety and health efforts this year in a sector that’s already dangerous. But depending on what state you work in, your chances of staying safe on the job site vary greatly. Let’s take a closer look at the top 10 most dangerous states for construction workers and the reasoning behind their risks.
#1 - Montana
OSHA Status: Federal OSHA
Employed Construction Laborers in 2021: 30,290
Employed Construction Laborers Rank: 40
Construction Fatalities Score: 1.32
OSHA Audit Score: 2.20
Final Score: 3.02
Montana has seen a sizable increase in population and construction jobs in recent years, but while it’s good for the state economy, it may not be good for construction safety. Federal data shows Montana construction jobs have surged by 11.4% in the past two years. But our data shows safety could be taking a backseat during this mad rush of building projects. Montana had one of the highest construction fatality rates (12.1) in the nation in 2021.
#2 - Kansas
OSHA Status: Federal OSHA
Employed Construction Laborers in 2021: 57,500
Employed Construction Laborers Rank: 32
Construction Fatalities Score: 2.09
OSHA Audit Score: 2.03
Final Score: 3.58
Like in many states, Kansas contractors are facing a dire labor shortage. Some reports suggest Kansas’ construction industry will need 58,000 new entry-level employees over the next five years to replace retiring Baby Boomers. The lack of workers could be one reason construction work in Kansas was so dangerous in 2021, as existing employees are stretched thin. Kansas’ construction fatality rate (14.9) was the nation’s second highest in 2021.
#3 - Florida
OSHA Status: Federal OSHA
Employed Construction Laborers in 2021: 398,060
Employed Construction Laborers Rank: 3
Construction Fatalities Score: 2.28
OSHA Audit Score: 2.27
Final Score: 3.62
A weakening economy may slow things down soon, but Florida’s real estate market has been red hot in recent years, keeping contractors busy. But like Montana, all the frenzied activity and building projects can easily lead to danger. Florida had the third-largest construction workforce in the U.S. in 2021 but also one of the most dangerous. Combine that with a state where OSHA enforcement has been lacking, and it has been a lethal recipe.
#4 - Nebraska
OSHA Status: Federal OSHA
Employed Construction Laborers in 2021: 46,270
Employed Construction Laborers Rank: 35
Construction Fatalities Score: 2.52
OSHA Score: 2.26
Final Score: 3.77
Nebraska is another state that had a high construction fatality rate (11.5) in 2021 and has seen lackadaisical OSHA enforcement since 2017. Very few OSHA construction inspections in Nebraska result in citations, and penalties have likely been too low to motivate some of the state’s worst contractors into compliance. Labor shortages are also complicating things for Nebraska contractors, so much so that many business leaders have convened to push for immigration reform to solve the shortages.
#5 - Colorado
OSHA Status: State OSHA Plan
Employed Construction Laborers in 2021: 137,060
Employed Construction Laborers Rank: 13
Construction Fatalities Score: 2.39
OSHA Audit Score: 2.38
Final Score: 3.79
If less stringent OSHA enforcement leads to worse safety outcomes, Colorado could be a good example of why. Colorado ranked 13th nationwide in the number of construction laborers, and the State OSHA agency has conducted 1,210 job site inspections between 2017 and 2023. But too few inspections have led to citations, and when there are penalties, they tend to be too low. OSHA fines per laborer in Colorado hover around $15, which puts them on par with other dangerous states like Arkansas and Florida.
#6 - Arkansas
OSHA Status: Federal OSHA
Employed Construction Laborers in 2021: 44,830
Employed Construction Laborers Rank: 36
Construction Fatalities Score: 1.6
OSHA Audit Score: 2.4
Final Score: 4.05
The labor shortage in Arkansas is so bad that state lawmakers have rolled back child labor protections that make it easier for children under 16 to get hired, possibly for construction jobs. Arkansas isn’t the only state doing this, as Minnesota and Iowa are considering similar policies. Considering that Arkansas had the second-highest construction fatality rate in the nation in 2021 (18.4), the new child labor laws could prove dangerous.
#7 - Minnesota
OSHA Status: State OSHA Plan
Employed Construction Laborers in 2021: 107,180
Employed Construction Laborers Rank: 21
Construction Fatalities Score: 2.59
OSHA Audit Score: 2.98
Final Score: 4.05
As we mentioned, Minnesota lawmakers are also considering relaxing child labor laws that would make it easier for contractors to hire 16-and-17-year-olds. Some contractors think the benefits outweigh the drawbacks, but it remains to be seen. In the meantime, construction workers in Minnesota are already suffering high injury and illness rates. Minnesota had one of the highest construction injury and illness rates (4.9) nationwide in 2021.
#8 - Georgia
OSHA Status: Federal OSHA
Employed Construction Laborers in 2021: 140,930
Employed Construction Laborers Rank: 12
Construction Fatalities Score: 1.53
OSHA Audit Score: 2.70
Final Score: 4.08
One reason construction safety is so poor in certain states is because of a lack of investment in safety education and training. Judging by the overall wages of Georgia construction laborers, that could be the case in this state. A recent study found that 44% of construction workers’ families in Georgia are enrolled in one or more welfare programs. If wages for Georgia construction workers are that low, it’s hard to imagine the investment in training employees on proper safety and health is much better.
#9 - Oklahoma
OSHA Status: Federal OSHA
Employed Construction Laborers in 2021: 79,440
Employed Construction Laborers Rank: 28
Construction Fatalities Score: 1.65
OSHA Audit Score: 2.56
Final Score: 4.14
OSHA only conducted 563 construction inspections in Oklahoma between 2017 and January 2023, resulting in just 396 citations. This is partly why Oklahoma had one of the lowest OSHA Audit scores among the states we analyzed, and it could also be the reason for OK’s high construction fatality rate. The state’s construction fatality rate of 15.6 ranked as the third-worst nationwide in 2021.
#10 - Indiana
OSHA Status: State OSHA Plan
Employed Construction Laborers in 2021: 125,390
Employed Construction Laborers Rank: 16
Construction Fatalities Score: 2.60
OSHA Audit Score: 2.39
Final Score: 4.16
Construction work zone safety is a big problem nationwide, but it’s especially acute in Indiana. Fourteen construction workers were killed, and more than 650 laborers were injured in work zones in 2018, according to the Indiana Department of Transportation (the most recent data). Along with the lack of work zone safety, Indiana construction workers have other problems. Fines for construction OSHA violations were just $6 per laborer in 2021, one of the lowest in the nation and not nearly high enough to deter unscrupulous employers.
Full Ranking Table of All U.S. States
How do all states stack up? We combined the eleven individual factors into two broad categories to create the Fatality and Injury Score and the OSHA Audit Score. Dig in below to see how individual states fared.
Conclusion
Contractors have much on their minds in 2023, and many things keep them up at night. The pandemic-induced supply chain problems still haven’t cleared up, leading to material price increases and project delays. A labor shortage that has been brewing for years is reaching crisis levels in some areas, with some positions harder than ever to fill.
Amid all this uncertainty, worker safety, and health should never be far from the minds of construction companies. Better workplace safety leads to lower workers’ compensation costs, higher employee morale, and reduced liability.
For construction laborers, safety is an obvious concern, and your chances of a safe workplace may depend on where you live. According to our analysis, construction workers in states like Montana, Kansas, and Florida may be in more danger than anywhere else in the nation. Increased OSHA oversight in these places could save many lives and help more construction workers return home to their families each night safe and soundly.
Methodology
To find the most dangerous states for construction workers in America, we analyzed all 50 U.S. states and the District of Columbia by several criteria. Four states were excluded from the ranking because of a lack of key Bureau of Labor Statistics injury, illness, and fatality data: South Dakota, North Dakota, Rhode Island, and New Hampshire.
We compared every U.S. state and the District of Columbia across 2 key categories and a total of 11 individual factors:
- Total Employed Construction Laborers (May 2021 Estimates). Census.
- Total Construction Fatalities (2021). BLS and State OSHA data.
- Fatalities per 10,000 Construction Workers.
- Construction Total Nonfatal Injury and Illness Rate (2021). BLS and State OSHA data.
- State Nonfatal Injury and Illness Recordable Rate (2021). BLS.
- State Workplace Fatality Rate. BLS.
- Construction Fatality Rate (2021). BLS.
- OSHA Construction Inspections from 1/1/17 to 1/31/23 - Ogletree Deakins OSHA Tracker.
- OSHA Construction Inspections per Laborer from 1/1/17 to 1/31/23 - Ogletree Deakins OSHA Tracker.
- OSHA Construction Citations from 1/1/17 to 1/31/23 - Ogletree Deakins OSHA Tracker.
- OSHA Construction Citations per Laborer from 1/1/17 to 1/31/23 - Ogletree Deakins OSHA Tracker.
- OSHA Construction Citation to Inspection Ratio.
- OSHA Construction FInes from 1/1/17 to 1/31/23 - Ogletree Deakins OSHA Tracker.
- OSHA Construction Fines per Laborer 1/1/17 to 1/31/23 - Ogletree Deakins OSHA Tracker.
We scored each factor with an equal-weighted score (where 10 is the highest score). We then averaged the factor scores within each of the categories listed above to find each individual category score. Then, we normalized the category score so that the highest-scoring state within each category received a high score of 10 (the highest score).
The final score was calculated by averaging the score of the 2 categories, then normalized to produce the final score and ranking.
About The Author
Edited by:
Bryan Huynh
•
Product Tester & Writer
